"We can easily forgive a child who is afraid of the dark; the real tragedy is when men are afraid of the light"- Plato

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Good Little Girls

In this video, the eight year old girl explains how she relaxes and finds a balance in the stresses of life. Though the stressors faced by today's children ARE a lot more different than in the 19th century, the way we are encouraged to handle ourselves despite being in stressful situations remains the same. I feel like the underlying message of the video is finding healthy ways to manage stress levels and control our impulses, we, as the little girl said need to "try our best and try harder". In the readings, it says that Gerty "had other less pleasing impulses" (p.133) that needed to be controlled that required conscious effort. When Gerty threw the rock at Nan Grant's wall, that was completely impulsive as just minutes before, Gerty was afraid to as much as pass the house. After, "she felt unhappy in her little heart. She did not understand herself, or her own sensations" (p.134) The need for balance and way to handle our impulses properly is displayed here.

In the same way, the little girl in the video was introduced with impressive credentials, even before we meet this girl, our expectations were high. People today are held to a high standard by what we do and it wasn't different in the 19th century. Finding balance and ways to promote that balance is important in dealing with events in our lives that are stressful.

I believe that things would have totally been different if Gerty was on the show. Anna, the girl on the show, handled her stress in a healthy way. Gerty acted on her impulses and I think that would be the focus of her interview instead of ways in which Gerty does promote the balance in her life. I feel like the show would be very humorous and would focus on what Gerty did such as throwing rocks at Nan Grant's window and her desire to beat up the girl from school. However, we see here that Gerty controlled her impulses by running from what she wanted to do instead of working through it. I feel like if Gerty would be in today's society, she would be encouraged to work through the situation in order to control her naughty impulses instead of being encouraged, as she was by Miss Emily to "be good, and love everybody" (p.149). In today's society, she would have been given a "how to" in doing better and would have more guidance. Just as in the video the girl SHOWED Amy Poehler how to do yoga and taught proper techniques. She didn't just say go do yoga to release negative energy, there were lessons involved.

5 comments:

  1. Hey Anna!
    I felt the same way about the underlying message of the video interview. I thought that the interview provided girls with a healthy technique for finding balance in their lives. Gerty finds balance by expressing her violent emotions and this is not a safe way method, she could really benefit from hearing Anna’s story, and how she uses yoga to calm her.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Gerty seemed to be the opposite of the girl on the show. The girl on the show managed her stress through yoga. Gerty doesn't know a good way to de-stress and takes her anger out by throwing a rock through a window. Had she had people who cared about her throughout her life she would have learned ways to keep herself under control. Because people don't treat her with respect, she engages in antisocial behavior.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Anna,

    Now that I've read your post there do seem to be more similarities between Gerty and Anna then I thought. The main difference between the two *could* simply be that one of them copes with their stresses better than the other. I think modern girls don't differ too much from 19th century girls. They are still require to control themselves with grace and make it look easy. Nowadays there's just more to deal with.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great points! I really agree with you about how the main focus of the show would have shifted if Gerty were on it. Anna, as you said, deals with her stress by balancing out her life, whereas Gerty acts on her impulses. You tied it together perfectly by stating that this has something to do with the time change as well. Awesome comparisons & great blog!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I feel the same about the comment you said about ways of coping with stress. This girl in this video is looking to deal with stress issues by using Yoga as her balance tool. It differs widely from the girls back then because of the way our society has changed today. Girls in recent years were viewed as human beings that looked out for each of their family members as well as their own well being. Because our culture has changed today, it has led to a very different view of young women.

    ReplyDelete